Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Pacquiao vs Bradley: Potential Undercard Fighters

First step is admission

As is famously said in 12 step programs

We admitted we were powerless ...

MLS has done just that, they admitted that Weyland had a bad day.

"He is an experienced referee who didn't have his best day," MLS executive vice president Todd Durbin said of Weyland in a statement. "As we saw in the recent UEFA Champions League semifinals [a controversial draw between Chelsea and Barcelona], referees in soccer will always come under scrutiny because their decisions can have significant impact on the game. But that is a function of the sport, not our league. It happens throughout the world."

Durbin added: "If a referee is not performing well, U.S. Soccer has, and will, remove that official from future MLS matches."

Star-divide

This is a solid step by the league. Weyland has a history. John Carver was fined for his criticism of Weyland after a poor game against FC Dallas, as well as the SuperClassico where 31 fouls were called. Oddly, though Weyland gives out more cards, and calls more fouls, many around the league think that the problem isn't that he calls them, but when they are called. After about a half hour Weyland seems to try and regain control of matches that he has lost.

General Manager Adrian Hanauer brings up a great point about the refereeing and the need for changes in the game.

"It's bad for the game when people think that there's too much embellishment, that the refs are too much involved, when the fans don't understand why these injustices appear to occur," Hanauer said. "In every other sport in this country there are more officials, more review of plays, less severe punishments handed out for more severe infractions of the rules."

Hanauer said with respect for the laws of the game and working with FIFA, "when a guy like Kasey Keller {vs. Kansas City] sits out an extra game for a play like questionably handling the ball intentionally out of the box, and another player gets an extra game for elbowing someone in the head [Fredy Montero vs. Chicago] or a significant punch or an extremely violent tackle, it just seems that the laws aren't very well calibrated for the fans. So that's just an area of concern for me."

It seems that MLS will likely have to make some changes. These changes will likely center around video review of calls and non-calls, an extension of the policy that lead Jamie Moreno to getting a one match suspension for a foul that was never called.

But what all MLS fans must realize is that officiating in every league is always questioned. It will never be perfect, probably never be good. I'm not just talking about the Champions League SemiFinal, but this weekend the Dallas Mavericks lost a game because a referee refused to call an obvious foul. We Seattle fans saw a Super Bowl that was lost due to poor refereeing. Every sport, every league has these same issues.

The key is how they are addressed and what is done to improve the situation, and to rectify injustices.

That first step is admitting that there is a problem, MLS at least got that right.

Comment 2 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

The only ref I can think of that was universally acknowledged to be a consistently good ref was Pierluigi Collina.

As for Weyland, if this last week’s game were an aberration in a record of consistently good performances that would be one thing, but unfortunately the opposite is true. Weyland has had at least three horrible performances as a ref this season and what MLS needs to realize is that while dedicated fans will remember the name of the ref responsible, most everyone else will associate the game what got horribly out of control with MLS. In a couple weeks Weyland will be forgotten, but the black mark will live on for MLS.

by CarlosT on May 12, 2009 3:30 PM PDT reply actions  

Here is an article by Paul Gardner in which he trashes Seattle officials’ comments about the bad refereering on Sunday. Unfortunately Mr. Gardner missed to watch the game before commenting on it and his analysis is off point. Mr. Gardner is widely read so please go to his article and straigthen the record by telling what you saw. The more postings, the better! http://www.socceramerica.com/blogs/soccer_talk/?p=123.

by Dragos Axinte on May 14, 2009 3:00 PM PDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Sounder at Heart is a blog about the Seattle Sounders FC, with occasional forays into Democracy in Sports, Roster Management, Soccer Statistics and Life in Puget Sound. We are not the actual Sounders blog.

FanPosts

Sounder at Heart exists on Facebook - Like Us

Follow SounderAtHeart on Twitter

Sounder At Heart on Twitter

follow me on Twitter

Follow the rest of us on Twitter

Sounder At Heart (Site Feed)

Sidereal (MLS stats)

Jeremiah Oshan (top 10 soccer journalist on Twitter, Baby!)

Aaron Campeau (Villa, Mariners)

Dave Clark (beer, specfic, mideast)

Brian Floyd (all Seattle sports)

Nos Audietis (podcast stuff, snark)

Chris Coulter (photos, academy)


Managers

Tiny_dave_with_scarf_small Dave Clark

Oshan_small Jeremiah Oshan

Seattlesoccerscene_small sidereal

Nos Audietis Crew

Avatar_small Aaron Campeau

220070_1878927565922_1023267281_32093127_6825812_o_small dano_seattle

Authors

Img_0349_small malcontentjake

Small dennyoffside

Ravelry_logo_small Abbott Smith

Special1tv_o_small Timm Higgins