Brian Schmetzer made no bones about his team’s struggles in his LAFC postgame press conference at the close of the regular season. “We’ve had some ups and downs. There’s some credence to the story that we’ve been a little inconsistent in some of our performances this year. And we can’t hide from that.”
No surprise that he didn’t choose to elaborate, but he is right and it feels a bit simplistic to leave it at that, without further exposition, considering how multi-faceted the reality of the situation is.
While mostly accurate at a macro level, simply pointing at “injuries” doesn’t quite capture the flavor of how unusual this year has been for the Seattle Sounders. Today I’ve gathered a few key numbers to tell that story more deeply, about why this team has felt so uneven, with numbers that may or may not soften your perspective on what just happened.
7
That supporters and coaches having the pleasure of a whole seven minutes of the best possible version of the Sounders in 2026 is an all-timer of a cosmic rug pull. The starting lineup on opening day lasted seven minutes before Jordan Morris sat down with non-contact muscle injury. Even now looking at this lineup you’d have to agree this should be Sounders strongest starting 11 on paper, absent Pedro de la Vega and pre-Dejan Joveljic.

Hassani Dotson did take the requisite six months to adapt to the Endless Rondo, and is still adjusting, but it does look like he’s bedding in. Swap out Deki for Osaze and the closest we came to this Day One lineup was a very good night in Boston.
12
Taking in the reality of Designated Player starts in recent years is a study in pain for the Emerald City Supporters. This year’s new nadir saw multiple DPs in the starting lineup just 12 times and a drop in DP minutes to a level not seen since the gap before Raúl Ruidíaz joined.
This team simply hasn’t been able to field its best group, all at the same time, in the regular season for a few years now. Subtracting the two overlapping starts in which Morris had to bow out early in the first half, his effective count of joint starting appearances of longer than 30 minutes with a fellow DP amounted to a measly 10 games in the 2026 season. Albert Rusnák had a very good overall assist count this year, but only one of those primary assists included Morris scoring a goal and that was after Albert was already off a DP contract.
Contrasted to how other top teams in MLS are finding success on the three-Designated Player roster model, the lack of time and synergy by the Sounders’ most expensive players is a problem, and has been a problem. Nashville and Miami both ended with more than 8,000 DP minutes and plum playoff positions, too. Nashville started at least two DP’s 30 times in 2026! Inter Miami started all three DP’s 24 times. Sounders have started all three DP’s in the regular season just 10 times over the last FOUR seasons.
58
Downstream of missing their DPs is the Sounders fielding a unique starting XI in 58 consecutive MLS regular-season games.
I’ll give you a chance to re-read that.
In addition to starting 34 unique lineups during the 2026 regular season, they’ve not repeated a starting lineup in the MLS regular season since April of 2025. Multiple re-injuries of Pepo and Jordan has meant lots of minutes to go around in attacking positions. You’d almost expect them to repeat a lineup by accident in that time…
Games 2 and 3 of the 2025 Best-of-3 playoff series against Minnesota did see a repeat starting lineup of what was arguably Sounders best 11 at the time on form. The two CCC games vs Vancouver this year also featured a repeat lineup with Paul Arriola and Jesús Ferreira as starting wingers. So Brian has stuck with a lineup, with mostly positive results, in non-season situations. In season, though, lineups have been consistently bespoke.
For two years running, the Sounders are averaging almost 3.5 changes to the starting lineup per game and butting up against Jim Curtin’s adage that four or more changes meant a team was dead-on-arrival more often than not.
Brian may genuinely believe that any team worth its mettle should be able to sustain this level of flexibility (albeit rarely by choice). That notion has been fully put to the test with decidedly mixed results. This year they did manage to survive. If only just.
0
Young players were thrown into the deep end this year and that drop off in experience has to be acknowledged as a contributing factor to how the season played out.
Zero MLS starts for 20-year-old Seb Gomez prior to August 2026. He ended on almost 1,200 minutes.
Zero MLS starts for 20-year-old Stu Hawkins prior to July 2026. He finished with more than 1,200 minutes.
Zero MLS starts and only 11 MLS minutes for Peter Kingston prior to 2026. He peaked 1,000 minutes.
Zero MLS starts and only 7 MLS minutes for Antino Lopez prior to 2026. He earned more than 700 minutes.
39 starts for the under-21 crowd is a new high and frankly a crazy number when you consider this group is effectively a line change from the last few years of Obed Vargas and Reed Baker-Whiting accruing those minutes. 20-year-old Snyder Brunell coming in at 80% of Obed’s minutes total last year was not in anyone’s preseason prognostications. And though none of these guys made the league's official "22 under 22″ list, they arguably made a more select list by earning Schmetz's trust.
If we’re being honest with ourselves, Kalani Kossa-Rienzi’s 15 MLS starts prior to 2026 does not compare to Alex Roldan’s 150+ MLS starts at right back. Brunell stepping into the Obed Vargas role is big shoes to fill with just three MLS starts to his name before the season started and an MLS veteran nipping at his heels. Alex Roldan shifting to centerback hasn’t really been a problem, but he’s been beat up and neither he nor emerging rookie Hawkins is quite the same kind of protagonist that Yeimar projects onto a game, a role it turns out is critical to Sounders’ game model being the best version of itself.
In talking about what it took against LAFC in the post-game presser, Brian summed up the foundations of his game management philosophy with this makeshift group in his very first answer: “We had to suffer. Sometimes when you are being hard to beat, in those moments, it’s as good as being really, really good and scoring 4 or 5 goals. I’m still a true believer that defense wins championships.”
It is undeniably positive that the development pathways did mostly stand up to scrutiny for a second year running when the organization’s plans around their biggest players were scuttled, and they needed to dig deep. Part of why I watch is to see these players come into their own and bloom under duress. It was, however, inevitable that this loss of experience would come at a cost. A recurring theme for the post-World Cup Sounders was reckoning with that cost.
1
In spite of Brian’s longstanding emphasis on defense, avoidable defensive mistakes have been the scourge of this team for a good while now. So it’s no surprise that their sum total had Sounders on the rocks going into Decision Day and beyond.
“We can go back shoulda.. coulda… woulda… on any sort of various games. One point woulda… One point would have made a difference.” Brian talking like this at all at the close of the season speaks just how much this state of affairs is caught in his craw. It’s the overwhelming feeling I’m left with too after another unsatisfying year. Too often one mistake too many was the deciding factor.
No doubt each of us has a favorite brain fart or mental collapse that made you apoplectic this year, a back post run completely missed or a fumbled ball control leading to a damaging counter attack. Handing Joveljíc an easy goal for his former team is of course Exhibit A. Andrew Thomas completely misjudging the on-running Milan Iloski sticks out too. Jackson Ragen getting a bad red and missing the most important home game of the season also comes to mind, a situation repeating itself again tonight in the new most important game of the season. And they still haven’t got the stink off from the first half team breakdown against Montreal. Heck, simply avoiding a late penalty against San Diego would have moved the Sounders up to sixth.
I left quite a few worthy fumbles out, for everyone's benefit, because the litany of Sounders mistakes has been the story and is frankly embarrassing to ponder for too long. These moments in Sounders control that incomprehensibly flip out of their control blanket the narrative.
And yet, even sputtering up front through the eight-game losing streak, and even putting up a goose egg in the Cascadia Cup for the first time ever, a 50-point-plus finish was within reach. "It’s the hope that kills you" isn’t a pathos I’ve generally associated with being a Sounders supporter. This season, though, has properly qualified.
Asked about Real Salt Lake on Sounders Weekly, Paul Rothrock remarked “I honestly am not thinking about them. I’m thinking about us. If we come into that game with the right mindset, you know, I have a good feeling about it.”
On balance, the Sounders have been their own biggest enemy these last 34 games so fostering their own collective focus is as good a place to start as any. For years, the team's marketing has asked for their fans to give them their “Full 90.” A return to the team reliably delivering that themselves on the home pitch is both overdue and an absolute necessity from here on out.